How firefighter oral boards are really scored, from a retired fire chief who ran the hiring boards.
The CPAT is pass/fail. Pass it and you’re even with everyone else who passed. The oral board is where you get ranked, and your rank is what gets you hired.
Most candidates prepare for the board by memorizing lists of questions and polishing answers. Then they walk in and get scored on things they never saw coming. Before the first candidate sits down, the panel agrees on what a top answer contains. Every rater scores you on their own, and they write while you talk. When the pens stop, you’ve either finished or you’ve lost them.
This book shows you that rating sheet from the other side of the table.
Who wrote it
I’m Roger Waters. I spent 31 years in the fire service, from firefighter to acting fire chief. I ran the training division and the hiring and promotional processes at Greeley Fire, then did the same at Cloquet Area Fire District in Minnesota. I taught fire academy recruits at Aims Community College for 26 years.
My own first oral boards were bad. I was nervous, I rambled, and the panels saw all of it. Greeley hired me on my third try, after nearly three years of testing. Years later I was the one holding the scoring sheet. This book is what I learned on both sides of that table.
What’s inside
- How raters score you: what goes on the rating sheet, what we write down, and why rambling is the number one reason the pens stop.
- The 30 questions in disguise. Panels ask hundreds of questions, but underneath there are about 30, in six families. You’ll learn to spot which one you’re being asked.
- Building answers that score: STAR answers for “describe a time when,” situational questions, the integrity question and “tell us about yourself.”
- The hard questions: your resume, your past, ethics scenarios, other hiring lists, weaknesses and social media.
- Your closing statement, questions back to the panel, virtual and recorded interviews, and the chief’s interview.
- What comes after the board: background, polygraph, psych and medical.
- A two-week prep plan, plus the Oral Board Scorecard, a practice question bank, an answer worksheet and a department research checklist.
The polished candidate who scored low
One year a candidate came in with a resume as good as any we saw. He knew the testing process inside and out. Then every answer came out sounding like it was read off a page. We kept trying to find the real person in that chair, and we never did. He scored low. The panel is deciding whether it would trust you on a crew, and a recited answer gets in the way. The book shows you how to prepare your material so it comes out fresh every time.
Who it’s for
Candidates with an oral board coming up, and candidates who keep making the list without getting the call. If you’ve already been to a few boards, the scoring chapters will explain results that never made sense.
It won’t help if you’re looking for scripted answers to memorize. That’s the habit this book is built to break.
The details
PDF ebook, about 30 pages, sent as an instant download after checkout. $37, one time. If it doesn’t help you prepare, email roger@firefighterconnection.com within 30 days for a full refund.
No book can guarantee a score, a spot on a list or a job offer. This one reflects my own experience and opinions, not the standards or questions of any department I served with. Always follow the instructions from the department you’re testing with.